Are Audiobooks As Good As Reading? What I Like And Don’t Like

I have been devouring physical books and digital pages on kindle for years and I can’t imagine life without them. What I hadn’t done until recently was try out audiobooks… shocking!! So now that I have given them a go, do I think audiobooks are as good as reading?

Let me be honest, the thought of a random narrator telling the story whilst I sat around doing nothing was not appealing. But as I was cleaning the kitchen some time last month, I mused to myself “this would be so much better if I could hold a book whilst cleaning…” but that wouldn’t work. Obviously. Then I remembered audiobooks existed. And that maybe I should give them a try so that I have a book on hand for this kind of situation.

So to celebrate me finally stepping into the 21st century and finishing my first book on audible, I’m writing a post about what I like and don’t like about the experience. This might help you decide whether you want to give it a go or not!

What I Like About Audiobooks

Convenient

It’s true – audiobooks are hella convenient. And I can see why so many people started listening to them and have been hooked ever since. You can read a book whilst completing other tasks – need I say more?!

The fact that you can have an array of books on your phone that’s accessible 24/7 is pretty cool. Whether you’re doing a grocery shop, taking a walk, tidying your space, waiting for someone, commuting, travelling on a plane, cooking or getting crafty, being able to read a book at the same time is a game changer. And it can be a new book or a book you’ve listened to before and still have in your library.

library of books on a phone held on top of baking supplies; cookie cutters, sieve, rolling pin, flour on bench with cup of tea

Test a book out

Hear me out, you can listen to the audiobook version of a book and if you love it, then buy the physical copy! This way you don’t end up purchasing lots of books that you don’t enjoy. Your bookshelf won’t contain novels that you’ll never look at again, only the gems.

Being selective = perfect bookshelf. Is this an expensive way of reading and collecting books? 100%. But is it worth it? Definitely. Especially if you’re part of Bookstagram, Booktok, Booktwitter or any other bookish group that fawn over beautifully put-together bookcases.

Accessible to people who struggle to read

One of the most important points to make about audiobooks is that now it is possible for those unable to read words on pages to have access to the entrancing experience of living through the world of books. There are many reasons people might not be able to read or be comfortable doing it, and audiobooks are a way for them to not be excluded from finding and enjoying others’ literary works.

Better for the environment

Since audiobooks are held on a device and do not need to be crafted physically, they are arguably more environmentally friendly than books. When you listen to stories, you don’t contribute to the mass-production of books made in factories from trees felled from a forest.

are audiobooks as good as reading? audiobook on phone with headphones

Finish books quicker

This depends on how often and for how long you like to listen to the audiobook. But you’ll probably get through your TBR (to-be-read) list a lot faster this way. This is because of my first point, that audiobooks are extremely convenient and you can read as you do other things. You don’t need to find time to sit down for hours because you’ll be multi-tasking and getting through books on the go! The speed of the recording can be changed to 1.5x or 2x for faster reading, too.

You might even have a physical book going at the same time as an audiobook and be able to switch between them.

What I Don’t Like About Audiobooks

Not the same feel

If you’re an avid reader who finds joy in collecting and displaying books on your shelf like trophies then you’ll appreciate the art on the cover, the smell of the pages and the weight of the piece in your hands. You don’t get any of that with audiobooks which takes away some of the magic of the book.

When you listen to the voice that’s guiding you through the story, it’s a little harder to imagine the scenes without seeing the words on the page. It’s just not as immersive. At least, that’s my experience. But everyone’s brain works differently and I know others may have the opposite problem!

It all hinges on the narrator

Although I’ve only read 1 book through audible so far (it was over 800 pages though… that’s almost 30 hours of listening time), I can tell that the user’s experience of reading the book will depend entirely on the person that’s enacting it. The narrator’s voice, accent, delivery and pronunciation of certain words has the potential to ruin the experience. It could leave you noticing and hanging onto words and sentences instead of delving into the world and forgetting you’re reading.

If you’re thinking of trying out audiobooks, I would recommend listening to the sample of the book first. I listened to a trailer of one book and swiftly exited the buying page because of the narrator. Better safe than sorry!

narrator recording an audiobook

It’s more expensive

For some reason I had it in my head that audiobooks were cheaper than paperback and hardcovers. Boy, was I wrong. Have you seen the prices for some of these reads? I get it though, a lot goes into the production of the recording.

Whilst audiobooks are far more accessible to some people, it does come at a higher price, thus making it inaccessible for others. Thankfully, audible has a credit system where you pay a monthly subscription fee and get a credit each month. This credit can be used to purchase a book, and the monthly fee is less than the book price so it’s worth it. Saying this, I have heard that there are options for free audiobooks through libraries, so that’s something to look into if audible and other platforms are too pricey.

Easier to miss important details

Unlike reading words on a page, I struggle to retain every word spoken and properly take it in. This can lead to getting distracted from the book and having to rewind a little every now and then. I feel like I’m likely to forget key information, especially when I’m multi tasking. How do you take in every sentence when working on something else at the same time? Your attention is split, so you could miss something important and be utterly confused chapters later when that thing was entirely relevant to the plot.

You can’t go back and forth

If you revel in finding clues or are prone to jumping back in a book to remember a detail then you’ll struggle with an audiobook. Going back and skimming a page to find the scene you’re looking for is pretty easy in a physical book, a little harder on an e-reader, but almost impossible with an audiobook. Having chapters that keep playing on can be irksome if you missed something earlier on and now think it was a hint for something bigger to come.

Note that you can go back on audible, and the 30 seconds rewind is a great help when your mind has drifted off for a sec, it’s just that you can’t find a “page” you might be looking for further back in the book.

wired earphones on a page of a book

Conclusion? Yep, I Rate Them

In a nutshell, I would recommend audiobooks and I think for some people they are definitely as good as reading. After avoiding them like the plague and cringing through the first couple of chapters, I started to see the draw. They’re handy to have on your phone, ready to be listened to at any moment. I found myself looking for things to do just so I could put it on (I still can’t just sit down and do nothing whilst listening) therefore more cleaning has been done, more Pinterest browsing, and more walking! At the same time, I can see that some of the negatives of audiobooks could be deal-breakers for some people.

Do you think audiobooks are as good as reading? And if so, are they your preferred way of consuming a book?

house of sky and breath cover on a phone next to a flower

P.S. Incase you’re wondering, my first audiobook was House of Sky and Breath written by Sarah J Maas and narrated by Elizabeth Evans. This was a re-read, when I was gearing up for the release of the third instalment in the Crescent City series.

I’ve got an audible subscription so my experience with this is what I’m basing my opinions on; this is not a sponsored post, nor an ad.


Discover more from Miriam Elen

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments